Most Read Articles
Pearl Toh, 10 Oct 2019
Adding a LAMA* to the double combination therapy of ICS** plus LABA*** in a single inhaler improves lung function and reduces exacerbations in patients whose asthma is inadequately controlled with the combination treatment, according to the TRIMARAN and TRIGGER# studies presented at ERS 2019.
23 hours ago
Environmental quality and exposure to pollution may play a small part in the development of metabolic diseases, such as diabetes, a new study has found.
Tristan Manalac, 2 days ago
Sleep deprivation impairs adolescents’ long-term retention of classroom material, according to a recent Singapore study.
4 days ago
Eating alone may help in weight management as findings of a recent study suggest that eating with friends lead to higher food intake.

SAPIEN 3 better than ACURATE neo for TAVR in seniors

Tristan Manalac
08 Oct 2019

Elderly patients undergoing transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) for symptomatic severe aortic stenosis may fare better with the SAPIEN 3 prosthesis than with the ACURATE neo transcatheter heart valve, according to a recent study presented at the 31st Transcatheter Cardiovascular Therapeutics scientific symposium (TCT 2019).

“TAVR has become indispensable as a treatment for severe aortic stenosis across the whole spectrum of risks,” said Jonas Lanz, MD, MSc, lead author of the study. “However, the generalizability of outcomes observed from the landmark trials to all commercially available systems is limited by differences in device properties.”

After 30 days, the rate of the primary endpoint was 24 percent in patients who were given the ACURATE neo valve, and 16 percent in those who received SAPIEN 3. The absolute risk difference of 7.1 percent did not meet the requirements for noninferiority (p=0.42). [Lanz J, et al, TCT 2019]

The primary endpoint was a composite between safety and clinical efficacy measures: all-cause death, any stroke, major bleeding, major vascular complications, acute kidney injury, coronary artery obstruction, rehospitalization for congestive heart failure and valve-related dysfunctions requiring repeat procedures.

Disaggregation of the analysis according to the individual components of the primary outcome showed that, for the most part, ACURATE neo performed comparably to SAPIEN 3.

Exceptions included acute kidney injury stage 2 or 3 (3 percent vs 1 percent; difference, 2.1 percent; p=0.0340) and valve-related dysfunction (10 percent vs 5 percent; difference, 5.0 percent; p=0.0084), both of which occurred significantly more frequently in the ACURATE neo arm. The difference in all-cause death rate (2 percent vs 1 percent; difference, 1.6 percent; p=0.09) was of borderline significance in favour of SAPIEN 3.

Subsequent secondary analysis showed that SAPIEN 3 was significantly superior to ACURATE neo TAVR. At 30 days, the primary endpoint occurred with a significantly greater frequency in patients who received the ACURATE neo device (risk difference, 7.1 percent, 95 percent CI, 1.3–12.9; p=0.0156).

“The increased incidence of the primary endpoint in the ACURATE neo group was robust in per-protocol sensitivity analyses and was primarily driven by the increased proportion of patients with moderate or severe paravalvular prosthetic aortic regurgitation, as assessed by an independent echocardiographic core laboratory,” researchers explained.

In the present study, 739 eligible patients were randomly assigned to receive either the ACURATE neo (n=327; mean age, 82.6±4.3 years; 59 percent female) or SAPIEN 3 (n=367; mean age, 83.0±3.9 years; 55 percent female) device. Noninferiority of the interventions were assessed in an intention-to-treat population, with a risk-difference margin of 7.7 percent for the primary endpoint. A one-sided upper 95 percent confidence limit was set.

“As TAVR emerges as a valid treatment option for patients with severe, symptomatic aortic stenosis across all risk categories, high-quality studies comparing different TAVR devices are needed to provide sound evidence of the strengths and limitations of these devices, with the aim of optimizing device selection for individual patients,” said the researchers.

“The SCOPE I trial is one of the first studies to fill this important gap by reporting an early composite safety and efficacy endpoint to differentiate between devices,” they added.

Digital Edition
Asia's trusted medical magazine for healthcare professionals. Get your MIMS Doctor - Malaysia digital copy today!
Sign In To Download
Editor's Recommendations
Most Read Articles
Pearl Toh, 10 Oct 2019
Adding a LAMA* to the double combination therapy of ICS** plus LABA*** in a single inhaler improves lung function and reduces exacerbations in patients whose asthma is inadequately controlled with the combination treatment, according to the TRIMARAN and TRIGGER# studies presented at ERS 2019.
23 hours ago
Environmental quality and exposure to pollution may play a small part in the development of metabolic diseases, such as diabetes, a new study has found.
Tristan Manalac, 2 days ago
Sleep deprivation impairs adolescents’ long-term retention of classroom material, according to a recent Singapore study.
4 days ago
Eating alone may help in weight management as findings of a recent study suggest that eating with friends lead to higher food intake.